We found it! In a cabinet in the garage right where it should have been. This the third mysterious reappearance of objects in the last 19 days. They all center around the garage and the youngest cat. We are starting to believe he operates a sort of time portal.
After the first 2 things, last night we jokingly asked the little critter if he would please find the tool kit. Today we found it right where we had looked before at least 4 times. No humans have been unsupervised in our garage. Very strange.
