Been with AA for 17 years. Every year, renewal = last year + 50% battle, normally ends with last year plus a few quid.
Last year I had a break down. Recovered back to Horton from near Milton Keynes. This year's renewal was last year plus EIGHTY per cent. Phoned 'em for the usual battle but this year they'd only take off about £30. So I left.
Currently with Kwik Fit

as v cheap (but lots of limits) and will go with Headley at insurance renewal time.
Cheers