You assume that it is the manufacturer who defines product warranty rather than the law of the land.
Even without legislation, Neilda makes more sense. Judges are car owners too.
What car does Whitworth drive?
No I do not assume. It is you who has made the assumption of what I know and do not know. Furthermore, in my response (which you have quoted) I have not disagreed with the stance that "fair and reasonable" would be both the correct approach and the basis for any legal test.
As for what cars the directors of Morgan drive, what bearing does that have on a discussion regarding warranty claims? Unless you are inferring that they have modified their cars, in doing so they have done damage to said vehicle and are having them repaired under warranty?
