Interesting Lorne. I for my part when driving any Mog I have never had the 'urge' to raise the Top', but leave off the Other'
With Madame in the car it is usually 'Full Kit' as opposed to 'Full Monty'. For my benefit, please describe the 'sensation' in your usual eloquent manner!
At the risk of offending anyone, Audrey and I personally prefer the old style tops rather than the newer ones. You can do more with the older ones and when the new ones are down they leave a hump at rest, breaking up car's lovely lines.
With three Mogs, all with full gear in mohair), I have never had one with a leaking top. We carry top, tonneau and side screens in the car when traveling, along with sufficient luggage, tools and parts to travel forever.
We have many 6 variations of using the gear..dictated by the weather or the possible weather.
1.Side screens off, tonneau on and folded over the rear compartment.
2.Side screens on, tonneau on and folded over the rear compartment.
3.Side screens off, top folded and covering the rear compartment,
4.Side screens on, top folded and covering the rear compartment,
5.Top on, screens off
6.Full gear.
#1 is the best for the right day..open, bright breezy and you're a part of the world you travek through will all its noises smells and sights. This is the style we use 75% of the time, reflecting the wather we find. However, ioo cold when the weather is brisk and too windy and exhausting on a Motorway for too long.
#2. this one can take of many of the cons in #1 as the sidescreens remove a lot of the wind and allow the heater to keep the cabin cozy. However, the windcreens pen you in on the sides, like DHC doors do.
#3 This is a good style for a day that just might bring rain. Takes only a few seconds to get the top up and leaves you fully open 'til then.
#4 This a style we use when the weather is bad. It allows us to put up the top easily and be fully enclosed or put it down in seconds as well.
#5. We use this one when the weather is iffy or even if we have taken too much sun. It gives you full freedom at the sides and you'll like that...yet also provides a feeling of greater protection. It gives your passenger the ability to be heard, and warm up and she will like that. It protects you and she against the rain..until you find a dry place to put the sidescreens on. It is warmer and less windy.
#6 To be used when you have to or when you wish to make up time by using a Motorway. Claustrophobic and cozy.
Aesthetically, many people believe a trad looks its best with its top on. In any event, try #4. That may be the perfect compromise you are looking for.
Many people are, at first, nonplussed by the raw feeling a fully open trad gives and the easy view (looking down) people have you. I often recommend they drive their better half with the top up for the first few tours. That normally resolves the breaking in period. For Audrey and I, it often hits our mood perfectly.
Lorne