Click here to return to the home page.
Image of a road.
Who's Online Now
8 members (Themorganeer, CLPlusFour, RichardV6, Jon G4LJW, DJC, 1854sailor, BillHart, Sir Percival), 257 guests, and 10 robots.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Top Posters(30 Days)
John V6 69
DaveW 68
+8Rich 66
Newest Members
4199, GOFFO1965, Joske Vermeule, SBP17, Ulfulf
9,208 Registered Users
Newest Topics
Maybe an MX5
by howard - 23/07/25 04:10 PM
Dashboard Turn Signal Light
by Bob_Price - 23/07/25 03:37 PM
Ozzy Osbourne
by Burgundymog - 22/07/25 08:28 PM
Super Three chain drive conversion
by Alastair - 22/07/25 04:18 PM
M3W - Anyone know this car?
by Biggle - 22/07/25 01:40 PM
S&S X Wedge Engine Gasket Source
by Morgan Dude - 22/07/25 02:13 AM
Supermax sprocket
by Laurens - 21/07/25 08:26 AM
Latest Photos
Motorworld München
Motorworld München
by Oskar, July 20
visit to Classic Remise Düsseldorf
my book
my book
by Oskar, July 20
More Pictures of the MHR Visit
More Pictures of the MHR Visit
by DaveK, July 19
Visit to the Factory- Historic Morgan Group
Forum Statistics
Forums34
Topics48,343
Posts813,026
Members9,208
Most Online1,046
Aug 24th, 2023
Today's Birthdays
RedThree
Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Page 32 of 79 1 2 30 31 32 33 34 78 79
Image #747046 06/07/22 07:43 AM
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 11,861
Likes: 137
Scruffy Oik
Member of the Inner Circle
Offline
Scruffy Oik
Member of the Inner Circle
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 11,861
Likes: 137
Originally Posted by Image
I've not done any numbers but even at 500°c I'm not sure the stored heat would do more than supplement winter heating for a community.


An interesting exercise. Assuming ambient of 10C, heating 100 tons of sand to 500C puts something like 14 billion joules of energy into it, so quite a significant reserve. Then it becomes an issue of how much energy you can take out to balance the amount you can put in during the day - or how long you can get useful heat out of it if you don't put anything more in.

If the claim of 'months at a time' is translated to a slightly more believable 8 weeks, and it means we run the 'battery' back down to ambient, then we are talking about taking in the region of 11MW out, so enough to warm a reasonable number of homes even given some pretty large efficiency losses.

If we assume an average house needs 12KWh/ year for heating and use is concentrated into 200 days per year, then a village of 1,000 homes would need to draw around 60KWh/day. But we need to factor in efficiency losses, of which I have no idea. Let's assume the whole system is only about 25% efficient. That means our battery is going to have to be able to supply a steady 10KW, so well within the theoretical capabilities of a 100-tonne battery. And these things wouldn't need to be very big, 100 tonnes of sand is about 65 cubic metres, so the size of a small industrial unit/big shed would do it.

As you say though, this is just a reworking of the storage heater concept - which of course is itself a form of artificial geothermal energy. I suppose the advantage here is that it's pretty cheap to pile sand around heating coils rather than digging or boring holes to make ground source systems.


Tim H.
1986 4/4 VVTi Sport, 2002 LR Defender, 2022 Mini Cooper SE
Joined: Oct 2019
Posts: 5,046
Likes: 313
Charter Member
Offline
Charter Member
Joined: Oct 2019
Posts: 5,046
Likes: 313
I'm sure most people would be very pleased to heat their house on 12kwh for the year ... think there might be a few orders of magnitude need added to that.

🙂

K

Image #747058 06/07/22 09:00 AM
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 11,861
Likes: 137
Scruffy Oik
Member of the Inner Circle
Offline
Scruffy Oik
Member of the Inner Circle
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 11,861
Likes: 137
Originally Posted by Image
I'm sure most people would be very pleased to heat their house on 12kwh for the year ... think there might be a few orders of magnitude need added to that.

🙂

K


Oops, yes, it's MWh,not KWh

https://assets.publishing.service.g...old-Energy-Consumption-Affordability.pdf

So that would mean our sand battery would have to deliver 10MW, which might be possible given the heat capacity, but I suspect it would only really work for many fewer homes - or of course you could have a bigger pile of sand!


Tim H.
1986 4/4 VVTi Sport, 2002 LR Defender, 2022 Mini Cooper SE
Hamwich #747067 06/07/22 09:41 AM
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 3,665
Likes: 43
N
Talk Morgan Addict
Offline
Talk Morgan Addict
N
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 3,665
Likes: 43
Originally Posted by Hamwich
Originally Posted by Image
I'm sure most people would be very pleased to heat their house on 12kwh for the year ... think there might be a few orders of magnitude need added to that.

🙂

K


Oops, yes, it's MWh,not KWh

https://assets.publishing.service.g...old-Energy-Consumption-Affordability.pdf

So that would mean our sand battery would have to deliver 10MW, which might be possible given the heat capacity, but I suspect it would only really work for many fewer homes - or of course you could have a bigger pile of sand!



Yes, but how does it heat these houses? The method? Calling it a battery implies electric recovery doesn't it? Or are you suggesting blowing air through it down pipes to houses?
Nick

Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 1,793
Likes: 47
Talk Morgan Enthusiast
Online Content
Talk Morgan Enthusiast
Joined: Jan 2010
Posts: 1,793
Likes: 47

Joined: May 2010
Posts: 9,285
Likes: 69
S
Needs to Get Out More!
Offline
Needs to Get Out More!
S
Joined: May 2010
Posts: 9,285
Likes: 69
When I saw the term “sand battery” I thought..
How the #### is that going to work? How can sand be used in a battery?
Reading about it I realised it is a variant of storage heating. The usual media hype providing clickbait.
We’ve had storage heating for decades. Solar panels heating water that is stored in a tank/ heat exchanger, geothermal in places like Iceland, air source/ ground source heat pumps being the latest must have.
There is a lot of overselling in the media for air/ ground heat pumps. New, well insulated buildings are ok but older not so. A bit like solar in that it was a good buy with the high feed in tariffs but the maths very marginal for cost- benefits now. EV ownership and battery storage might help, though.
It is only a matter of time before fuel duty gets transferred to EV’s. smart meter variable costing too.
Covid, Ukraine have highlighted a poor long term strategy for fuel supply with self sufficiency being changed to buy it in.
It takes a “crisis” to refocus the strategic plans to stimulate development and change.


Plus Four MY23 Furka Rouge
nick w #747079 06/07/22 10:42 AM
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 11,861
Likes: 137
Scruffy Oik
Member of the Inner Circle
Offline
Scruffy Oik
Member of the Inner Circle
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 11,861
Likes: 137
Originally Posted by nick w
Yes, but how does it heat these houses? The method? Calling it a battery implies electric recovery doesn't it? Or are you suggesting blowing air through it down pipes to houses?
Nick


Hot water circulation. You are absolutely right, it's not a battery at all, it's a heat storage/recovery system. As many others have pointed out, hysterical and inaccurate reporting by the media is completely unhelpful.

I reckon the narrative that they are trying to push is that one day someone's going to come up with a silver bullet solution that solves all our energy problems and enables us to carry on as we are. You see it time and time again whether applied to sand batteries, hydrogen cars, fusion power or anything else.

The dangerous subtext of course is that we can therefore all carry on as we are now without making any adjustments, because the magic answer is just around the corner.


Tim H.
1986 4/4 VVTi Sport, 2002 LR Defender, 2022 Mini Cooper SE
Hamwich #747080 06/07/22 10:48 AM
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 11,861
Likes: 137
Scruffy Oik
Member of the Inner Circle
Offline
Scruffy Oik
Member of the Inner Circle
Joined: Apr 2008
Posts: 11,861
Likes: 137
Originally Posted by Hamwich

So that would mean our sand battery would have to deliver 10MW, which might be possible given the heat capacity,


Well, my efficiency and capacity estimates were way off.

Apparently it can store 8MWh and deliver it at a nominal 100KW. So probably ok for a contribution, but you'd need to go large (or have plenty of them) to make a significant difference. Interesting approach though.


Tim H.
1986 4/4 VVTi Sport, 2002 LR Defender, 2022 Mini Cooper SE
Joined: Oct 2019
Posts: 5,046
Likes: 313
Charter Member
Offline
Charter Member
Joined: Oct 2019
Posts: 5,046
Likes: 313
Best I can glean from the reports air is circulated through the sand and then a heat-exchanger to heat water to feed the community heating system ... presumably using water direct on 500°c sand would be a bad idea and defeat the object of being a largely passive system without the complex engineering of superheated steam turbines etc.

Makes perfect sense that if your big need is for energy in the form of heat that you don't go swapping through different energy forms .... just turn excess power into heat and store it like that, then use it direct.

Not a new idea by any means ... can remember 35 years ago when I was setting up off grid the use of stacked matt-black 50 gallon drums of water or a big thick stone wall behind a south facing glazed wall being used in the same way (heated by the sun during the day then then giving up it's heat to the house during the cooler night ... either passive or fan assisted .... worked best for the old hippies in New-Mexico ... and still seen in the 'earthship' houses there today.)

Everything else is just media hype and the poor levels of science education amongst our journalists.

K

Image #747100 06/07/22 02:17 PM
Joined: Dec 2017
Posts: 2,041
Likes: 71
Talk Morgan Expert
Offline
Talk Morgan Expert
Joined: Dec 2017
Posts: 2,041
Likes: 71
Originally Posted by Image
Awesome ... the Finns have reinvented the Storage Radiator! 🙂

K


I remember how efficient they were cold snow


Bruce
1964 4/4 Series V Comp (Megan)
1994 +8 (Maurice)
2013 M3W (Olga)
Page 32 of 79 1 2 30 31 32 33 34 78 79

Moderated by  TalkMorgan 

Link Copied to Clipboard
Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.5