but I don't think anyone has yet suggested a Boxster Spyder
Shall I?
This is my "comfortable car", next to Violet.

It's light, comfortable, pretty fast, the bikini top is not really a pain to mount it (takes a couple of minutes max), the PDK it's a good compromise (of course manual would have been my first choice but it was too expensive), plenty of space in the cabin and for luggage. Porsche build quality and somehow practical.
Just make sure to have the bucket seats and the sport "system" in case you have the PDK else the gearbox will not be as fast as it could (this can be installed as Porsche tequipment/aftermarket option).
It will not get too much wow factor since for lot of people it's "just a boxster", up to you if it's a pro or a con.
For any doubt/question, I am here.