
Let's try (including me) not to confuse people. The era is a mess already with owners more likely to get the wrong part than the right one from most suppliers, aside from very astute Morgan players, is flamboyantly unreliable. The Plus 8s, NAS and LRUK era from 1990 to 2004 is horribly confusing enough.

My best advice is to take pictures for re-supply. I have referred to both Morgan and other water pumps and front covers gomog, DEs Hammil (the famous writer of HOW TO POWER TUNE ROVER V8 ENGINES lists no less than 8 types of timing covers,
So for what it is worth.
The body will be the same, so that will fit.
Definitely not The water pump bodies are quite different.I can think of 5, three of which the MMC used iin different times and places...and after 1996ish the stopped match the times and places used by LRUK or LRUS, That is why another why (3.9)
timing cover is needed for these cars. The 3.9 water pump difference is the long extension at the bottom that Crimson Red mentions and a much higher extension of the pump chamber above.
BTW, these water pumps are properly imaged by taking the shot immediately above when they are lying flat on the ground. Sadly we are taking the images from angles that do not easily see the differences easily..The pulley is definitely different, and I'm not sure why the MG version has that long attachment.
Pulley diameters are easy until one gets to the serpentine era. Timing covers covers from the first Buick 215s to the last one fit (1962 to the late 1980s and then up to the serpentine era) are all interchangeable with minor changes if any. The pulley diameter determines the water pump speed and, of course, the fan belt you must choose. These timing covers are inaccurately called timing covers as they are
much more than merely covers. They are key engine components as they incorporate oil pumps, distributors and water pumps, which covers of other cars rarely do. That makes them important complex components performing multiple tasks and
there are many enhancements possible, primarily from our American Buick 215 cousins. The bigger water pumps were thought needed for the coolant demands of a 4x4 truck rather tha hyper sports car.
Morgan switched from Rover setups to 4x4 Land Rover setups in 1986. Des Hammil, one of my favorites and the author of "How to Power Tune a Rover V8 Engines", lists no less than 8 different "timing covers. Morgan used many but that is not understood by owners who apparently thing all timing covers are the same. The kaleidoscope of options from around the world make these engines a tuner's delight and a great hobby. Even some of the Downunder ideas are great.
I believe the pulley bolts on to the flange at the bottom of the long attachment with three bolts and the fan bolts on to the top with four bolts.
Correct, the fan bolts are the same unless you have a vicious fan which ca easily be ground off. One can swap around pulleys, increasing or slowing pump speed. One can even swap in a speed adjustable electric pump. (I am NOT a fan (PUN!) This observation here (not only mine) is based on the logic that the quicker the water flows, the less time the radiator has to cool it and the less time that water had it has to cool the engine..as it is rushes through at a higher speed. Each engine setup has a water coolant speed with its own sweet spot..a trial and error job once one leaves the fold...and best compromises are the norm.
For et up, one begins by working out a goal tht suits delight and usage. In my case, I was shooting for an ultimate flexibity and reliable Plus 8. I forgo tuning to well-over 300 bhp (which I can arrange in minutes), as Rob Wells was correct discovering that bhp over 275 makes it impossible to get power to the ground with stock sized types, (I settled at 282
though I can tune to 306bhp) And I am looking for reliability. Road going Morgans do not have an adjacent race track paddock and a beer meters away at all times. I tune/cam my mog to best perform. I have marked higher tuning needs on the engine if I am competing. Takes seconds. My limit is that I do not like tyres that are not standard size. But all this is merely me. I am a long distance mogger by preference, not often a racer.
A wrod of advice. JHS2, 25 years ago, told me to find my favorite Morgan roads and set up my cars accordingly. He was an auto crosser. I am a long distance mogger. And though I will admit to enjoy scaring the kids with their Japanese 4 bangers, I also like gliding silently in at 50-60 on pretty country roads.
With 80 years of option, a Rover Plus 8 can reflect your personality, AND, without leaving the comforting fold of other owners. Does anyone really care that you ported your exhaust or intake, or matched your exhausts to your preferred engine tuning, Manufacturers are cost conscious...and forgo the best to save money. And even companies like TVR changes engines, not Morgan. But TVR does not tailor engines to their buyers, only to a different, more aggressive common template. Plus 8 engines can be tailored to each of us without significant cost unless you hire people. We might not be trained as mechanics, but that is not a bad thing. This is not rocket science....of at least prior to the GEMS change (1998 for (US) and 2000 US). It is less complicated that following recipes.
gmg.
P.S. BTW, I had a possible epiphany on your 1995. In that year (IIRC), Land Rover had begun their move to the later GEMS systems, including a change in cover timing cover and pump. For a short time, they used an "interim front covers", that still used a distributor but drove the oil pump off the crankshaft rather than the camshaft system (1962-1995). AFAIK, Morgan never used that interim cover. But engine/gearboxes are delivered to the MMC assembled. It would be very possible that an engine would be delivered with that interim cover system. A phone call could have the MUCH earlier timing cover and pump sent to replace it. Actually, that would not a bad thing for the reasons given I gave previously. You have far more aftermarket options and you have no need to change the entire front covers 500£. Even the earlier pump can be repaired or tuned.
As I mention often, Rover V8s are more like wine. Their year does not mean "better" merely another vintage