Originally Posted by IanClarkeUSA
Originally Posted by PaulV
Originally Posted by LightSpeed
...
Our diesel electric boats in the navy and the ferry systems don't have giant batteries for storing power, they just regulate the power to the electric motor. The first diesel electric boats in the navy might have been submarines and they needed batteries for running submerged, and I doubt the M3W will need that requirement, but in England one never knows :-)

The only battery necessary would be the engine starting batter which we already have in place.

As to electric efficiency, the efficient part is the engine running at a more constant rpm if you vary voltage with a big rheostat rather than varying engine rpm.

As Centa drive M3W owners note, a marine application is much more constant speed than a car. wink
Pretty sure a rheostat is an inefficient variable resister you would NOT want on an EV! But some other controller for sure smile
Nissan's engine tech is a bit like you describe - engine drives generator drives motor. However they still put a battery in between the generator and the motor for better response, regeneration etc.

My Ford Maverick Hybrid has a 1.1Kwh HV battery to store power from regeneration, its also used to start the engine, so you don't need a very large HV battery. The Fisker PHEV project had a 20.1Kwh HV battery equaling a electric only range of under 30 miles https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fisker_Karma


A hybrid a a very different animal than an power unit producing power only when the engine is running. The hybrid complicates things and by eliminating the big battery, the transmission, the clutch, driveshaft and bevel box and replacing those things with a generator and an electric motor on the rear wheel I bet there would be a weight savings.


The light at the end of the tunnel is actually a train. 2019 M3W