Originally Posted by Neilda
Originally Posted by TheCustomer

Setting aside all the emotional pulls of actual engine dynamics, my barrier to EV is charging anxiety. My hybrid fills with petrol in 5 minutes, and charges while parked & I'm eating/sleeping or working. Any other attempt to charge on the move is likely to add more stress and anxiety than range.

Will


Most people will charge an EV overnight - and keep it topped up overnight - meaning a 300 mile full tank every morning. I very rarely use the Tesla superchargers - I topped up in Birmingham recently on a trip up to the midlands, 20 minutes. I've just worked out that I've saved 68 visits to a petrol station since I've had it and used superchargers about 6 times.

As I rarely drive over 300 miles in a day I have yet to suffer from range anxiety. This sets aside the thousands I have saved in fuel and servicing costs.


I'm sure.

My observed experience is that on a 140 mile each way commute, when I make a service station stop for a mid journey comfort break, I've seen all the fast chargers occupied... tales of woe on the work car park chat as colleagues try and fail to find a charger that works (20-30% don't, and there's no effective plan in place to fix it), colleagues having charging cables locked into chargers, and a colleague who drives an Audi EV finding that his chosen charging stop on the route home was shut... I don't have time for that malarkey.

So on a weekly near 300-mile round trip, that would require EV charging at some point, over the past six months I've become less convinced that I could reliably leave home with a full charge, splash & dash top up en route while on a comfort break, fill up in the company car park, and get home without having to make a forced stop to charge. Some of my overnight stops have chargers, some don't. If I were in an EV I'd likely restrict myself to places I can charge, which isn't always where I want to stay.

Why does this matter? It's at best a 2 1/2 hour journey, which I try to get through as quickly as reasonably possible (within speed limits :-) ). Life's too short to also have to work to manage the charge in a car.

Yes, it's an unusually long commute I'm doing, and for my particular needs right now, 50mpg in a hybrid that's fully charged when I leave home is a reliable way to travel. Fully charged with carbons & electrons I have 440 mile range - a third more than I'd need to do a round trip without refuelling. Only a Merc EQS at over £100,000 can give the same range today: I suspect that in 2024 or 2025 there would be more choice, and perhaps at more affordable prices.

Curiously, today I make money on my client's expensed ICE travel: I'd lose money claiming their EV allowance.


Formerly Aero S5 #80
Currently 911 (992) Targa in python green